Short answer: A declined Wikipedia draft is not the end. Reviewers at Articles for Creation decline a draft with a stated reason, most often that the sources do not show the subject is notable or that the text reads like promotion, and you can fix those problems and resubmit. A rejection is firmer and means the reviewer sees little chance of the draft working as it stands. Most declines trace back to sourcing, not to how well the draft is written.
1. Declined, rejected or just waiting
The notice on your draft tells you which situation you are in, and they need different responses.
| Status | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Pending | Waiting for a volunteer reviewer; it can take a while | Do not resubmit or ask repeatedly; improve the draft while you wait |
| Declined | A reviewer found fixable problems and gave a reason | Fix the reason, then resubmit |
| Rejected | A reviewer thinks it is unlikely to meet the standards as it stands | Do not resubmit unless something fundamental has changed, such as new independent coverage |
Wikipedia's reviewers are volunteers, so neither a decline nor an acceptance is something you can buy or negotiate, and no service can honestly promise a particular outcome.
2. The usual decline reasons and what they really mean
- Notability not shown. The sources do not demonstrate that the subject meets the notability guidelines. For companies the bar is stricter, see Wikipedia's NCORP guidelines and the organizations and companies guideline. This is a sourcing problem.
- Insufficient or unreliable sources. Your own website, press releases, sponsored articles, social media, directory listings and interviews where you do the talking are not independent. A reliable source is independent of the subject and has editorial oversight.
- Reads like an advertisement. Superlatives, marketing phrases and a company-centered voice break the neutral point of view rule. This is a rewriting problem.
- Not verifiable. Claims without inline citations to a source a reader can check.
- Copyright concerns. Text copied or closely paraphrased from your site or a press release.
3. How to respond to a decline
- Read the notice and any reviewer comments carefully. They are the most specific feedback you will get.
- List every source and mark each one independent or not. Be strict. If only a couple of sources are independent and have real depth, not passing mentions, the draft will probably be declined again. There is no fixed number, but experienced reviewers look for several independent sources that cover the subject in substance.
- Rewrite in a neutral, factual voice. State what independent sources say, in plain words, and remove anything that sounds like a pitch.
- Disclose any conflict of interest or payment. If you are connected to the subject or being paid, say so on your user page and the draft's talk page, as the conflict of interest guideline and the paid-contribution disclosure rule require. See what the paid-editing policy requires.
- Ask for help before you resubmit. The Teahouse is a place where experienced editors answer questions from newcomers.
- Resubmit only after real changes. Sending the same draft back is the fastest route to a rejection.
4. When to rebuild instead of patch
Patching a draft works when the subject has strong coverage that the draft simply failed to use. Rebuild, or wait, when:
- Most of the citations point to the subject's own material.
- The draft was written from the company's or person's point of view rather than from what others have published.
- The honest answer is that independent coverage does not exist yet. In that case more writing will not help. Earning real press coverage first will.
Also note that drafts nobody edits for six months can be deleted as abandoned under Wikipedia's speedy deletion criteria, though they can be restored on request through requests for undeletion.
5. Where outside help actually fits
The most useful thing an outside expert can do after a decline is an honest notability review: check whether the sources are there before you spend time on another submission. That review can tell you what to fix or whether to wait. It cannot promise acceptance, because Wikipedia's volunteer reviewers decide. If you are weighing paid help, read what to check before you hire a Wikipedia editor, and see how my Wikipedia page creation and notability service is set up, including the disclosure rules above.
Before another attempt, run your sources through the free Wikipedia notability checker to see what a reviewer is likely to discount.
FAQ
Can I resubmit a declined Wikipedia draft?
Yes. A decline is feedback, not a final verdict: you can improve the draft and resubmit it for another review. Resubmitting without changing anything that the reviewer raised usually ends in another decline, and in some cases a rejection.
- A decline lets you fix the problems and resubmit.
- Resubmitting unchanged tends to lead to another decline or a rejection.
What is the difference between a declined and a rejected Wikipedia draft?
A declined draft has fixable problems, most often weak sourcing or promotional tone. A rejected draft is one the reviewer believes is unlikely to ever meet Wikipedia's standards in its current form, so it should only come back if something fundamental changes, such as new independent coverage.
- Declined means fix and resubmit.
- Rejected means the topic or sources need a fundamental change first.
Why do most Wikipedia drafts for businesses get declined?
Usually because the sources do not establish notability. Company drafts lean on the company's own website, press releases, interviews and paid placements, none of which count as independent coverage. The tone is the second most common problem: text that reads like marketing copy.
- Sourcing is the most common cause, not writing quality.
- Promotional tone is the second most common cause.